Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Harper's exploitation of the Main Stream Media

NOTE: Original written by Scott Johnson - republished from www.UysFaber.com

During Canada's 41st election, the media was either exploited, greedy, or a combination of the two.

I'm going to start by pointing to the Kent Commission and Davey Report (Royal Commission on Newspapers), and particularly a statement in the section "Key Findings":

" the Commission concluded that the profession’s primary responsibility was "searching out and reporting the truth." "

I may be naive, but that sounds like a journalist's job description, and the Kent commission concurs, even if the statement is optimistic and ideological.

The voting public does rely on journalists to inform themselves about political events.

In a way, you could ask that if a politician stole a dollar, but it was never reported, did it really happen? Of course it did, but they would get re-elected!

The media's failure begin with their coverage of the reason why Canada was having an election.

The Liberals put forward and passed a motion of non-confidence in the sitting government. The stated reason for the motion and vote was the 'prima facie' case of contempt found by the Honourable speaker of the house.

Regardless of the poor tactical decision by the Liberals, miring the contempt ruling in a partisan vote, the historical event of a sitting government being found in contempt was a first for a Westminster system - globally.

The Government had literally been found withholding information from the democratically elected representatives of the people. Maybe it's just me, but that sounds like a breach of the public trust. That should have been journalistic gold.

Now to be fair, the media did cover the contempt ruling, as evidenced in this McGill analysis of newspaper reporting, but the upcoming budget with its looming deficit actually outranked the contempt coverage leading up to the drop of the writ.

Why is that important?

"Public opinion responds not to events or social trends themselves, but rather to reported events." [1]

The above quote is from an award winning University of Chicago press book, which studied American public opinion and behaviours over a 50 year period.

Like it or not, the choices of editors can sway public opinion.

In this light, it is legitimate to ask who the editors of Canada's newspapers support, and if it is representative of public opinion.

In the last three elections, editorial boards of 75% or more Canadian papers that endorsed candidates supported the Conservative party. We are all human, but this consensus of opinion should give cause for reflection, especially when looking at which stories get multiple days of exposure. I don't believe that this is some Orwellian plot, but given the harmonic editorial mindset, it becomes easy to argue that their reporting probably tended in Harper's favour rather than against it, albeit subconsciously. In fact, one can even show through the above McGill research that Harper and/or the Conservatives are mentioned first in newspaper articles 51% of the time or greater during the entire campaign, reaching 66% in week three. Harper didn't even receive 50% of the vote, but Harper was mentioned more times than both Layton and Ignatieff combined for 4 out of 5 weeks during the campaign.

Trying to stay empirical, I'll use the McGill research again, looking at the week of March 21-27. This is two weeks after the speakers ruling, and the week the Liberals pass their motion of non-confidence.

Already the theme of "coalitions" has rocketed into heavy usage, surpassing "contempt" by over 50%. "coalition" is the most mentioned political news item, even though the election is only called on the 25th-26th.

This can be partially explained by Liberal leader M. Ignatieff's stumbling out of the gate with an incoherent position on the topic. He did attempt to clear up confusion the next day, by stating emphatically that he would not enter into a coalition agreement.

Theoretically, this should have resulted in a visible tapering off of coalition coverage, but the following week (March 28-April 3) the word "coalition" appeared 449 times. That's over 50% of the articles surveyed in the McGill research. To put that in another perspective, the word "contempt" was mentioned 503 times from the period of March 14th till May 1st.

Again, to be equitable, Conservative leader Stephen Harper, as well as his entire party, used the word at each and every opportunity. The term "coalition" was being used by the Conservative Party as a form of scaremongering, as well as branding. This was clearly a marketing strategy by the Conservative party, demonstrated by repeated commercials for months prior to the election.

Given that this was a platform issue for the Conservatives, the media had a duty to analyze the CPC statements. Instead they just repeated them.

CBC personality Peter Mansbridge actually spent three of his leader interviews on the topic of coalitions, and barely challenged Stephen Harper when he flagrantly disagreed with facts. Academics and legal experts were rarely consulted or interviewed.

Meanwhile, constitutional experts were frothing at the misinformation being spouted by the incumbent Prime Minister.

Peter Russell is man often quoted in the media as a constitutional expert. He made a desperate cry for the education of the public regarding the contempt ruling, posted through this video.

Again, being fair, CBC did do one broadcast citing Peter Russell as an expert, and attempted to educate the public on how our system of democracy functions.

Just one broadcast citing an expert for the most publicized topic of the 41st election campaign.

Considering that the term "coalition" was a Conservative marketing strategy, Stephen Harper couldn't have paid for better coverage.

What makes it funnier is that Stephen Harper disdained any unscripted media contact, limiting reporter's questions, as well as fencing them off from events, as evidenced by this CTV video.

Stephen Harper played the media so well that when Terry Milewski tried to ask a question he was drowned out by the local crowd, their outburst inspired by Harpers handlers. This attempt to silence the reporter became the story, and his question become a foot-note. The question was regarding a suspected terrorist financier in the Air India bombing being courted by a Conservative candidate.

All these factors encumbered the media, allowing them no 'new' material from the Conservative Party, instead forcing the Press to repeat Harpers mantra like speech.

But that's not entirely true.

Harper didn't run a smooth well-oiled blue machine. All of the events I'm about to list below were only discovered during the election campaign (36 days). Think about that as you read the list.

Harper's campaign was marred by no-show candidates at debates, Bruce Carson (a story that still isn't over), Party Organizers being charged with election violations, a leaked auditor general's draft report that accused the Tories of misleading Parliament on G8 spending projects, Sebastien Togneri - who is under investigation by the RCMP for meddling in ATI requests - is found volunteering in Edmonton, allegations that Harper's chief spokesman peddled influence in Quebec, the aforementioned religious extremist support, the contempt issue, the release of evidence (or lack thereof) used to boot Helena Guergis from caucus, an anti-abortion Conservative candidate bragging about the defunding of an international agency that promotes family planning, and lastly speculation that a CPC contender promised immigration papers through his connections to the Minister of Immigration.

The last one was sloughed off by the media as commonplace in Ottawa. It seems complacency is common as well, since this detritus of scandals consistently received less coverage than "coalition".

At no point during the campaign did the "coalition" story lose its solid and unchallenged throne as the top media story, accumulating a massive 1290 mentions in newspapers, compared with the next closest term, "deficit" at 884.

All Four national political parties put forward "deficit" reduction plans, but only one party flogged "coalition".

Which brings us to the surprising cohesion of support for the Conservative party from newspaper editors nationwide. Private newspapers are expected, to a minor extent, to have a pro business bias. This is the nature of the beast, as they themselves are private enterprises. The pro business bias in this election was that the Conservative party was the only party offering corporate tax-cuts, which if it did not directly benefit the smaller corporation, would certainly enrich their parent conglomerates. (There are only 4 or 5 media companies in Canada)

However, considering how journalists were treated by the Conservative party, their endorsements are nothing less than a complete affront to their profession.

Given the secretive nature of Stephen Harper so often described by the media, and the recent SCC decision that the public does not have a right to access documents in the offices of cabinet ministers or the prime minister, I'd say journalists have had their jobs spun out for the next four years.

In modern slang, that's an Epic Fail.

Even a CBC political correspondent, late in the campaign, posted an open question on twitter

"Is this our fault? I know I ask this every now and then, but I'm starting to feel really guilty and responsible. Us being the media."

I believe that empirical evidence does show that journalists didn't perform their job, and failed the Canadian public.

If I still haven't convinced you, perhaps L. Martins article in the Globe and Mail entitled "Has the fourth estate lost its tenacity?" will show that my opinion is something journalists are even asking themselves.

My questions for journalists country-wide is this:

How does it feel to be used like a tool?

[1] page 340, The rational public: Fifty Years of Trends in Americans' Policy Preferences by Page and Shapiro, University Of Chicago Press; 1 edition (March 1, 1992)

Friday, April 29, 2011

Electoral question re:Newspaper endorsements (updated)

To whom it may concern,

I am concerned that several Canadian newspapers have decided to endorse political candidates in the 2011 election campaign.

While I am not perfectly clear on recent changes and new technicalities, it would seem that their endorsements constitute Third Party sponsorship. The editorials cost the private companies money, through manpower, printing costs and other expenses.

While I understand that 3rd parties can advertise during an election, I was under the impression that they are required to register with Elections Canada.

In particular, I am writing to ask if the Globe and Mail registered as a 3rd party, or if any members of its editorial board registered as a 3rd party. If not, could you please explain why their endorsement is not a violation of current Election financing rules?

Thank you very much for your time, and Thank you for the excellent work you perform on behalf of all Canadians.

Regards,

Elections Canada response (received with 24 hours of query!)

Title,

You are correct that third parties who incur more than $500 for election advertising are required to register. However, the statutory definition of "election advertising" (s. 319 of the Canada Elections Act) specifically excludes from that definition "the transmission to the public of an editorial, a debate, a speech, an interview, a column, a letter, a commentary or news". In accordance with this definition, an editorial or column endorsing a party or candidate is not considered to be election advertising.

I trust this is of assistance.


Not only was the EC response quick, but it was technically specific. To say I am impressed is an understatement.

Monday, April 25, 2011

The 5 point plan the Liberals won't use

The Liberal campaign for Canada's 41st election is floundering, if not outright choking. Their "platform" is poorly articulated, and it comes across exactly how people view Ignatieff.

The biggest failure is preaching democracy and strategic voting in the same sentence. Attack Harper, do not mention Layton!!!

The 5 point plan: is an spoken slogan - and its requirement is it's brevity and order. No need to alter web-platform.

1. Fiscal responsibility creates a better economy - and we have a proven record

2. Families - families need better jobs, great schools, and the best health-care. Only successful families build a better economy.

3. Defence and Crime: Canada's forces deserve the best equipment, and our veterans better treatment. We will also focus on Crime Prevention. Protection is better than punishment.

4. Restoring our International Independent reputation. We are our own country.

5. Cleaning up the environment. The oil sands are here to stay, but we can be cleaner. Green is the future.

When asked why the change in platform? I've listened to Canadians.

I actually don't agree with these policies, but I like a spicy campaign, and a jerk-sauced Parliament. Hence the Liberals should be using the 5 pointer above to hit on the Conservative vote.

- just offering my pennies.

Canadian politics would be boring without minorities! (oh wait...)

Thursday, April 7, 2011

Real Senate Reform

A brief proposal for senate reform (light draft)

Replace the senate every election, but with the popular vote percentages.

All parties would have to present their ranked list of Senators prior to the election, so the candidates may be scrutinized. No surprises.

This would be an honest reflection of Canadian voting intentions, while not infringing on local representation, as well as leaving parliamentary house power intact.

When it comes to voting there are two options

1 - leave it the way it is

2 - provide the ability to vote for a local candidate and a federal party (I could vote for a local Conservative, but also vote for Liberal 'Sober Second Thought')

Obviously, the rules and powers of Senators would need to be reviewed, but it would provide the chamber of sober second thought with an actual mandate from the people.

What the approximate Senate distribution would have been after the last election

CPC 40 seats
LPC 28 seats
NDP 19 seats
Bloc 10 seats
Greens 7 seats

To reply, find me on Twitter.

Regards,

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Rules for Radicals

A short primer on Saul Alinsky; America's most effective radical.


Saul Alinsky is generally considered the father of community organizing, and one of Americas most effective radicals. His last book, Rules for Radicals, is one of the best primers in power tactics and effective methods of change. It was written in 1971. He died in 1972.

Alinsky is reviled by Catholics, feared by corporations, and compared to Osama Bin Laden.

As a criminologist in Chicago in the 1930’s, he quickly concluded that a massive portion of crime had a direct correlation to poverty. He realized that to combat crime, one must first take on poverty. In his new aspiration, he discovered that a lack of organizational prowess and power left the common person unable to defend their own rights. He devoted himself to making people self sufficient in these respects. He believed in democracy. His book “Rules for Radicals: A pragmatic primer for realistic radicals” was the culmination of his theories.

This work seems largely ignored, and underrated by activists, but corporations alone take his theories very seriously. Here is an excerpt, from a book published by the The Lukaszewski Group. The L.G. specializes in Management Communications Consultancy, which comprehensively provides Activist Counteraction tactics. One of the L.G.‘s well known clients was Enron, when they had a Communications Crisis in 2002. James Lukaszewski, the founder, lectured in Milan, in 2003, for seminars sponsored by AssoComunicazione ; a group representing more than 189 national and international advertising and public relations companies.

If this communications expert takes Alinsky to heart, why haven’t more progressive social movements made use his methodologies, or expanded them?

New World, New Rules

Alinsky states unequivocally, in his book, that protests are a known tactic and a piece of history. New tactics must be adopted.

He lists thirteen rules for power tactics in the book, and reiterates that the list is by no means exhaustive or concrete. His rules are:
  1. Power is not only what you have but what the enemy thinks you have.
  2. Never go outside the experience of your people. When an action is outside the experience of the people, the result is confusion, fear, and retreat.
  3. Wherever possible go outside of the experience of the enemy. Here you want to cause confusion, fear, and retreat.
  4. Make the enemy live up to their own book of rules. You can kill them with this, for they can no more obey their own rules than the Christian church can live up to Christianity.
  5. Ridicule is man’s most potent weapon. It is almost impossible to counterattack ridicule. Also it infuriates the opposition, who then react to your advantage.
  6. A good tactic is one that your people enjoy. If your people are not having a ball doing it, there is something very wrong with the tactic.
  7. A tactic that drags on too long becomes a drag. Man can sustain militant interest in any issue for only a limited time, after which it becomes a ritualistic commitment.
  8. Keep the pressure on, with different tactics and actions, and utilize all events of the period for your purpose.
  9. The threat is usually more terrifying than the thing itself.
  10. The major premise for tactics is the development of operations that will maintain a constant pressure upon the opposition.
  11. If you push a negative hard and deep enough it will break through into its counterside; this is based on the principle that every positive has its negative.
  12. The price of a successful attack is a constructive alternative. you cannot risk being trapped by the enemy in his sudden agreement with your demand and saying “You’re right—we don’t know what to do about this issue. Now you tell us.”
  13. Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.

Legacy

The organization he started, the Industrial Areas Foundation, still exists today and is continuing to build its core. They even offer paid tryouts to become permanent staff.

Alinsky’s foundation, the IAF, and its affiliate organizations designed and passed the nation’s first living wage bill in Baltimore in 1994 and in New York in 1996. The IAF East affiliates launched a lawsuit against the Honeywell Corporation, which resulted in a ruling for Honeywell to spend up to $400 million removing toxic chromium from New Jersey City sites.

“The IAF is non-ideological and strictly non-partisan, but proudly, publicly, and persistently political.”

In his primer, he does not discuss issues but rather how to organize and effect change. For a book written in the seventies, it is surprising to find that most of the content is still relevant today. Anyone interested in being part of the process of change should certainly take a few notes from this book, regardless of your cause.

As Alinsky said:
Once you accept your own death all of a sudden you are free to live. You no longer care about your reputation…you no longer care except so far as your life can be used tactically — to promote a cause you believe in.